Are Auctions an Appropriate Way to Allocate Microwave Spectrum?

frequency auction imageRecently the U.S. Congress requested information from the FCC regarding the usage of the 11, 18 and 23GHz microwave point to point bands. This move is seen by many industry watchers as the first step in preparing these bands for auctioning.

Auctioning spectrum is seen by many in the political establishment as a good way of raising large sums of money.  The 3G auctions in Europe raised $30 billion in the U.K. and $45 billion in Germany and although these figures will probably never be reached again, the attraction for governments trying to balance the books in an economic downturn is clear to see. However, these figures were for cellular access spectrum and there is evidence of microwave spectrum auctions being priced too high for operators and no bids being received, e.g. the original 28GHz auction in the U.K during 2000-2002. But even if the bidding process itself is successful, is granting large amounts of spectrum to a single operator the right way to allocate microwave spectrum?

Let’s look a little deeper into how microwave spectrum is used and allocated in most cases today in licensed common carrier frequency bands. An operator wanting to install a microwave link between points A and B would seek to obtain an individual license for that link in that specific location and frequency. This allows others to apply for other frequencies or even the same frequency in different locations.  This approach maximizes use of the available spectrum.

Now let’s look at the block licensing approach. Here a block of spectrum (either on a national or regional basis) is allocated to one user. Block allocations on a regional basis make sense for multipoint applications like fixed wireless access or mobile network applications. However, in the case of point to point (PTP) allocation a block license holder may not have requirements for that entire spectrum, but because it is now their spectrum, no one else can gain access, often resulting in under utilization. This is the situation currently with the 38GHz band in the U.S. and is leading to some in the industry to push for the availability of additional spectrum.

Another example of this is the 28GHz LMDS band, where service take up has been very low, but has effectively blocked out this band from other uses/users. Another concern for the block licensing approach and one that affects equipment vendors is that with fewer operators there are fewer equipment contracts thus leading some manufacturers to be “frozen” out of the market. This will ultimately reduce choice for all and reduce innovation and competition.

Referring back to the announcement, it makes no mention of what would happen to the holders of existing link licenses who will have engineered their networks based upon the current rules. What would happen to these links should that band now be auctioned off as a block? Spectrum auctions also break the U.S. into many smaller regions, with each regional block license being auctioned to the highest bidder. This leads to the question of demarcation and coordination between adjacent regions, particularly for links that may need cross-regional boundaries.

All in all, it would appear that based on evidence to date, auctioning FCC Common Carrier microwave spectrum will be tremendously complicated and likely not in the long term interests of the industry.

Ian Marshall
Regulatory Manager
Aviat Networks

Markets

Aviat is pioneering wireless solutions across diverse industries, driven by customer challenges. Explore Now
$
Mobile Operators
$
WISPs
$
Public Safety
$
Government
$
Utilities
$
Oil & Gas
$
Mining
$
Transportation

Products

Aviat's products offer unique, tailored solutions, ensuring optimal performance and cost-effective network design. Explore Now
$
All-Outdoor Radio
$
Microwave Indoor Units
$
Microwave Routers
$
Split-Mount Radio
$
All-Indoor Radio
$
Microwave Trunking
$

Virtual Fiber PTP/PMP 

$
Private LTE
$
Network Management

Hosted Softare

Aviat's hosted software streamlines network management, ensuring efficient, accessible, and reliable solutions. Explore Now
$
Aviat Design
$
Frequency Assurance Software
$
Health Assurance Software

Services

Aviat offers tailored services optimizing wireless infrastructure, from project management to continuous support Explore Now
$
Project Services
$
Managed Services
$
Support
$

Education & Certification

Explore Company

Aviat Networks delivers reliable wireless transport solutions, backed by 70 years of expertise and a strong focus on customer satisfaction. Explore Now
$
About Aviat
$
Compliance
$
Responsible Sourcings
$
Leadership
$
Careers

Resources

Aviat's Resource Center offers a comprehensive collection of insights and tools to support your wireless transport needs Explore Now
$
Blog
$
Webinars
$
Collateral

Investors

Aviat Networks, Inc. is the leading expert in wireless transport solutions and works to provide dependable products, services and support to its customers. Explore Now
$
Overview
$
Press Releases
$
Events & Presentations
$
Financial Information
$
Stock Information
$
Investor Resources

Contact Aviat

Contact Aviat for network solutions, sales, support, and global locations. Explore Now
$
Discuss My Network
$
Schedule a Demo
$
Request a Quote
$
Request Customer Pin
$
Get Tech Support
$
Request an RMA
$
Upgrade / Buy License Key
$
Become Aviat Certified
$
Customer Training